What does strength refer to in mathematics?

My professors are always saying, “This theorem is strong” or “There is a way to make a much stronger version of this result” or things like that. In my mind, a strong theorem is able to tell you a lot of important information about something, but this does not seem to be what they mean. What is strength? Is it a formal idea?

Answer

Suppose you have a theorem that says “If X, then Y.” There are two ways to strengthen such a theorem:

  1. Assume less. If you can reduce the number of hypotheses, but still prove the same conclusion, then you have proved a more “powerful” result (in the sense that it applies in more situations).
  2. Prove more. If you can keep the same hypotheses, but add more information to the conclusion, then you have also produced a more “powerful” result.

Here is an easy example from Geometry.

Let ABCD be a (non-square) rectangle. Then the internal angle bisectors of the vertices intersect at four points WXYZ, which are the vertices of a rectangle.

(You need the condition that ABCD is not a square because if it is a square then all four angle bisectors coincide at a single point.)

Here are a few ways to strengthen the theorem:

  1. The hypothesis “ABCD is a (non-square) rectangle” can be relaxed to the more general “ABCD is a (non-rhombic) parallelogram”. The conclusion that WXYZ is a rectangle still holds.
  2. Alternatively, you can keep the original hypothesis that ABCD is a (non-square) rectangle, and strengthen to the conclusion to say that WXYZ is not just a rectangle, but a square.
  3. Having done that, you can then strengthen the conclusion of the theorem even more, by noting that the diagonal of square WXYZ is equal in length to the difference of the lengths of the sides of ABCD.
  4. Once you know that, you can now strengthen the theorem even more by (finally) removing the hypothesis that ABCD is non-square, and including the case in which the four angle bisectors coincide at a single point as forming a “degenerate” square with a diagonal of length zero.

Attribution
Source : Link , Question Author : Zachary F , Answer Author : mweiss

Leave a Comment