Can manholes be made in other shapes than circles, that prevent the cover from being able to fall down its own hole?

Circular manholes are great because the cover can not fall down the hole. If the hole were square, the heavy metal cover could fall down the hole and kill some man working down there.

Circular manhole: Circle

Can manholes be made in other shapes than circles, that prevent the cover from being able to fall down its own hole?

Semi rigid math formulation:

Let us say that we have an infinite matematical 2D plane in 3D space. In this plane is a hole of some shape. Furthermore we have a flat rigid 2D figure positioned on one side of the plane. This figure has the same shape as the hole in the plane, but infinitesimal larger.
Is it possible to find a shape, where there is no path twisting and turning the figure that brings the figure through the hole?

Here is one such shape (only the black is the the shape):Five side

But if one put the restriction on the shape, that it needs to be without holes (topological equivalent to a circle in 2D), then I can not answer the question!?

Edit:

Because of the huge amount of comments and answers not about math, I fell the need to specify that:

I am not interested in designing manholes. I am interested in the math inspired by the manhole problem.

Answer

Any manhole cover bounded by a curve of constant width will not fall through. The circle is the simplest such curve.

Attribution
Source : Link , Question Author : hpekristiansen , Answer Author : Michael Hardy

Leave a Comment